the hair stroking incident at night is therefore sudden and also strange, especially after Antolini has actually just won Holden"s trust prior to giving some sound advice. Yet do you think his subsequent action is just an chaste paternal type of gesture, or did he have some darker engine in mind? I tend to think that Holden"s reaction alone provides the event not okay, no matter what Antolini"s intentions may have been. Because that a teacher come stroke a student"s hair if he"s asleep, a time once we"re most vulnerable, an individual boundaries are being violated. Grandfather Antolini reacted through some embarrassment and seemed to make an effort to downplay the incident, saying that being captured took him turn off guard. His response, "I"m simply admiring you," is a little bit offish too. Also when Holden tries to rationalize the incident and wonders if he"d over-reacted, he still feels really uncomfortable around it. That alone renders it creepy come me, and also puts that in the category of something that need to never have happened. What do others think? Is Antolini a an excellent teacher or a creep?


You are watching: Catcher in the rye mr. antolini

Paula wrote: "That hair stroking incident at night is therefore sudden and strange, particularly after Antolini has just won Holden\'s trust before giving some sound advice. Yet do you think his subsequent action is just ..."\n\n' + $('comment_body_usertext').value;new Effect.Highlight('comment_body_usertext')" class="smallText" href="#comment_form">reply | flag *
together a teacher, Antolini stepped end the line, but he was likewise a friend of the family. Holden concerned him seeking assistance late at night. Antolini give him shelter and advice, an excellent advice, together a friend of the family not together a teacher.Still, the stroking the his hair do Holden uncomfortable. He to be no much longer the small kid Antolini had actually taught and known. Holdens discomfort signifies his maturation, his coming of age.I didn"t take it together a come-on however Holden did, and also he plot accordingly.If Antolini had invited him over, that would certainly be different, however Holden came to him in a time of need, and also Antolini took him in. Caressing his head to be an act of compassion the sprang from discovering him as a young boy. But Holden had changed. His denial of the gesture signifies his shift into manhood.
Monty J wrote: "as a teacher, Antolini stepped end the line, but he was additionally a girlfriend of the family. Holden involved him seeking support late at night. Antolini offer him shelter and also advice, great advice, as a frie..."\n\n' + $('comment_body_usertext').value;new Effect.Highlight('comment_body_usertext')" class="smallText" href="#comment_form">reply | flag *
Monty J wrote: "as a teacher, Antimony stepped end the line, yet he was also a girlfriend of the family. Holden pertained to him seeking support late in ~ night. Antolini give him shelter and advice, great advice, together a frie..."Yeah, the does sort of ring true. Maybe it"s no stretch to imagine that Antolini, with innocuous intentions, behaved as if Holden was still the son he"d known. Yet his failure (or one of them) was forgetting the he to be now handling a young man, which do the issue an ext complex. Of course it to be a bit various in the fifties. In the 21st century, it"s a dodgy move even if the college student was tho a kid.
Paula wrote: "Monty J wrote: \"as a teacher, Antimony stepped over the line, yet he was also a friend of the family. Holden pertained to him seeking support late in ~ night. Antolini give him shelter and advice, great a..."\n\n' + $('comment_body_usertext').value;new Effect.Highlight('comment_body_usertext')" class="smallText" href="#comment_form">reply | flag *
*
having actually read the the appropriate pages very closely many times and also discussed it through my very own students, I believe either translate is plausible. If the is true, it renders the passage all the much more effective, due to the fact that Holden isn"t sure and also the reader isn"t sure, therefore it bring the reader closer come Holden by sharing his view of simply not knowing.
bill wrote: "Having read the the pertinent pages very closely many times and discussed it through my very own students, I believe either translate is plausible. If the is true, it makes the passage all the an ext effec..."\n\n' + $('comment_body_usertext').value;new Effect.Highlight('comment_body_usertext')" class="smallText" href="#comment_form">reply | flag *
*
Paula wrote: "Monty J wrote: "as a teacher, Antimony stepped over the line, however he was additionally a friend of the family. Holden pertained to him seeking support late in ~ night. Antolini provide him shelter and advice, good a..."oooh an excellent answer
Wattt wrote: "Paula wrote: \"Monty J wrote: \"as a teacher, Antimony stepped over the line, yet he was also a friend of the family. Holden came to him seeking support late at night. Antolini give him shelter and a..."\n\n' + $('comment_body_usertext').value;new Effect.Highlight('comment_body_usertext')" class="smallText" href="#comment_form">reply | flag *
bill wrote: "Having check out the the pertinent pages closely many times and discussed it through my very own students, I believe either translate is plausible. If that is true, it provides the passage every the much more effec..."Yeah, it"s straightforward to imagine that"s just just how Salinger to plan it, which makes him a really great writer. I tend to think that he supposed no harm, however the truth that he waited until Holden to be asleep proves the he self knew it wasn"t a good move come make.
Paula wrote: "Bill wrote: \"Having check out the the appropriate pages very closely many times and also discussed it through my own students, I believe either translate is plausible. If that is true, it provides the passage every t..."\n\n' + $('comment_body_usertext').value;new Effect.Highlight('comment_body_usertext')" class="smallText" href="#comment_form">reply | flag *
Paula wrote: "...s Antolini a great teacher or a creep?"I"d to speak the man is a nice brilliant and also courageous teacher, the diametric opposite of Mr. Spencer. It was he who compassionately spanned then picked up James Castle"s human body after he committed self-destruction at Elkton Hills. Later, he absorbed Holden as soon as he called late at night, distraught and ill, then he offered Holden fantastic advice about getting a great education and prepared a bed because that him on his couch. Remember, he was not just a teacher however a friend of the family.Antolini is created on the an initial page of thing 23 together a courageously compassionate individual in the tenderness manner in which that protects Holden and his dorm-mates indigenous trauma through shielding the young students from viewing such a ghastly sight. He then more elevates himself by tendrely lifting the boy"s mangled frame and also carrying that away. (23,174) He to be the one that ultimately picked up that boy that jumped out the home window I told friend about, James Castle. Old Mr. Antolini feeling his pulse and also all, and also then the took off his coat and also put it over James Castle and also carried him all the means over to the infirmary. That didn"t even give a cursed if his coat gained all bloody.After together a dramatic display screen of compassion, Antolini"s tenderness toward Holden is completely in character. The Holden take it it together a come-on is much more a reflection him than Antolini. Holden was just as Antolini said, "... A really strange boy."Here"s several of Antolini"s advice:Antolini: (24, 189) "I"m not trying come tell friend that just educated and scholarly guys are maybe to contribute something an useful to the world. It"s no so. However I do say the educated and also scholarly men, if they"re brilliant and an innovative to start with--which, unfortunately, is seldom the case--tend to leaving infinitely an ext valuable records behind lock than males do that are merely brilliant and creative."That Salinger, a WWII combat veteran, was qualified of creating such complex and memorable personalities as Antolini, Stradlater, Mr. Spencer and also the prefer speaks highly of him. Such composing is rarely equaled.Here"s a connect to mine article, "Misjudging Mr. Antolini" on Wattpad.com: https://www.wattpad.com/58013882-midj...
Monty J wrote: "Paula wrote: \"...s Antolini a an excellent teacher or a creep?\"\n\nI\'d say the guy is a quite brilliant and courageous teacher, the diametric the opposite of Mr. Spencer. It was he who compassionately covered t..."\n\n' + $('comment_body_usertext').value;new Effect.Highlight('comment_body_usertext')" class="smallText" href="#comment_form">reply | flag *
Monty J wrote: "Paula wrote: "...s Antolini a good teacher or a creep?"I"d to speak the guy is a nice brilliant and also courageous teacher, the diametric opposite of Mr. Spencer. ..."Another point to think about is just how Antolini"s admiration for Holden fits right into the novel"s prevailing theme of maturation and the shift into adulthood. Antolini fills double roles of both family members friend and teacher. In both cases, he has an implied obligation to cultivate the boy so that will develop into a successful and also productive adult. Salinger characterizes Antolini as not just a excellent teacher but additionally hints that he may be a closet homosexual, making the a fascinatingly complicated character. The homosexual implications charge their interaction with sex-related tension. The large question here is even if it is a happy man have the right to compliment one adolescent male without being accused that pedophilia. Aide native Antolini"s gayness, together a family members friend, he to be acting the end a responsible nurturing function by providing Holden advice, calling him "handsome" and stroking his head. Every one of these gestures fulfill the "family friend" duty to shore up Holden"s self-confidence by reinforcing his positive qualities of intelligence, education and physical attractiveness. If Antolini to be an aunt and also did those things, couple of people progressive an eyebrow. But since Holden thinks he"s gay, he reaction homophobically, acquisition the reader together with him. Homophobia was common in the 1950s once this novel to be published, therefore it"s understandable the Salinger"s writing would certainly reflect the mores that his milieu.A family friend should have the ability to do what Antolini walk without gift accused of do a sex-related pass. However Holden"s overreaction characterizes him together both heterosexual and homophobic. Furthermore, his overreaction to represent a tires milestone--that he no only deserve to discern subtleties of happy behavior, but is likewise assertive sufficient to protect his masculinity. This is proof of Holden"s maturity. In ~ 17, Holden was no legally an adult, however his actions in this instance establishes that he"s mature sufficient to defend his masculinity.
Monty J wrote: "Monty J wrote: \"Paula wrote: \"...s Antolini a good teacher or a creep?\"\n\nI\'d to speak the guy is a pretty brilliant and also courageous teacher, the diametric opposite of Mr. Spencer. ...\"\n\nAnother point to ..."\n\n' + $('comment_body_usertext').value;new Effect.Highlight('comment_body_usertext')" class="smallText" href="#comment_form">reply | flag *
*
It appears Mr. Antolini has crossed his border line. Holden watch him as a caring teacher and also whether or not, Mr. Antolini is attracted to Holden, the border line have to not be crossed. I mean, Holden is simply 17. The is tho a teenager. In psychology, this is the stage wherein a human finds his identity, "Who am I?" If this stage is dissatisfied, it could lead to identification crisis. Somehow, Holden deals with his dilemm too. That smokes. That studies yet his grades suffer a lot. He engages in unnecessary fights. The is same to say as soon as Holden approaches Mr. Antolini, Holden is expecting a support from a fatherly figure, who can provide him inspiration, an inspiration and words to live by. Yet, a stroking event happened. Holden feel shocked by this inevitable. Even if it is Mr. Antolini appears to it is in closeted gay or not, he appears to give Holden a reason to feeling awkward and uncomfortable. His overreaction come the instance is the many common response we can get from a teenager like him.
Dean Ryan wrote: "It seems Mr. Antolini has actually crossed his boundary line. Holden look at him together a caring teacher and whether or not, Mr. Antolini is attracted to Holden, the boundary line have to not be crossed. I mean, Ho..."\n\n' + $('comment_body_usertext').value;new Effect.Highlight('comment_body_usertext')" class="smallText" href="#comment_form">reply | flag *
*
ns was proud the Holden for conveniently deciding the what Mr. Antolini was doing (patting his head in the dark while the was sleeping after ingesting a the majority of alcohol) was not OK and also taking that upon himself to leave the situation instead of enable anything much more to transpire. I think this was a fantastic example of specifically what a young person should do in a instance in i beg your pardon they space uncomfortable. Ns realize this was created 70+ year ago, however Mr. Antolini as defined by Holden had actually been demonstrating grooming habits including: Friendly through child external of institution environmentMaking in-roads through familyOffering a ar for Holden to sleepOffering Holden alcohol/cigarettesInsinuating Holden is for sure under his watchComplimenting his physics appearance (handsome, long-legs)Accusing Holden of over-reacting and also being strangeI agree with the posts above that Holden is the ultimate judge and he has been a negative one transparent the publication -but his actions right here were precisely correct.
Bionicjim wrote: "I to be proud the Holden for easily deciding the what Mr. Antolini to be doing (patting his head in the dark while the was resting after ingesting a the majority of alcohol) was not OK and taking it upon himse..."\n\n' + $('comment_body_usertext').value;new Effect.Highlight('comment_body_usertext')" class="smallText" href="#comment_form">reply | flag *
Bionicjim wrote: "I to be proud of Holden for quickly deciding the what Mr. Antolini was doing (patting his head in the dark while he was sleeping after eating a the majority of alcohol) was no OK and taking that upon himse..."I 100% agree with every little thing you wrote.
Joanna wrote: "Bionicjim wrote: \"I to be proud the Holden for conveniently deciding that what Mr. Antolini was doing (patting his head in the dark while the was resting after ingesting a many alcohol) was no OK and also ta..."\n\n' + $('comment_body_usertext').value;new Effect.Highlight('comment_body_usertext')" class="smallText" href="#comment_form">reply | flag *
Paula wrote: "Is Antolini a great teacher or a creep..."The trouble is that he to be BOTH, a an excellent teacher and also a creep. Thats what betrayal trauma is all about. When Holden freaks out, Antolini SHAMES him by telling him that he is strange, instead of reflecting compassion in a minute when Holden is feeling confused and scared. Prefer someone rather wrote, Antolini to be grooming Holden. The doesnt take far the truth that the was an excellent to Holden numerous other times. Thats what makes this sort of abuse therefore damaging.


See more: How Far Is Branson Missouri From Indianapolis Indiana, Flights From Indianapolis, In To Branson, Mo

Joanna wrote: "Paula wrote: \"Is Antolini a great teacher or a creep...\"\n\nThe problem is the he was BOTH, a great teacher and also a creep. Thats what treason trauma is every about. Once Holden freaks out, Antolini SHAME..."\n\n' + $('comment_body_usertext').value;new Effect.Highlight('comment_body_usertext')" class="smallText" href="#comment_form">reply | flag *